How To Choose The Best Dog Training Collar

We all love and care for our dogs, even when they disobey us, but it is hard to overlook when they attack friends or family who visit. However, there is no need to worry. I’m going to help you choose the best dog training collar perfect for any situation you may be facing.


Choosing a Dog Training Collar Based on Your Situation

Everyone has a dog that is causing trouble in their own unique way. Is your dog constantly running out of the door when you try to leave? Is your dog barking all throughout the night causing you to lose sleep, or is your dog chasing every animal they see when you take them for a walk?

Each situation calls for a different type of training collar to remedy it. So, before we get to some neat collars you can buy, we should discuss the different types of collars that are available. Each collar can be broken down into a general category.

Remote Shock Collars: Don’t Hurt That Cat!

training dog not to hurt cat

We have all seen the dog that absolutely hates cats. Some people even own dogs that hate all other animals and attacks without hesitation. For dogs who really are having a hard time listening to you when it comes to attacking, remote shock collars work the best.

Remote shock collars contain three pieces: a collar, a shock belt, and a remote controller. With basic shock collars, all you have to do is set your remote to the amount of shock you want to give (typically ranges from 1 to 100) and then press the punish button. It is a simple and self-explanatory mean of getting your dogs to behave.

If you’re like me though, you hate to hurt your dog. Any type of punishment just makes you feel like your dog will hate you. That is why I like the new remote shock collars.

They typically provide three separate functions: beep, vibrate, and shock. This way, you can choose to use the shock as your last resort when trying to get your dog to behave and listen.

Pinch and Prong Collars: When Your Arm Can’t Handle the Tugging Anymore.

Pinch Collars are exactly as they sound. They contain prongs that will dig into the skin of your dog’s neck. Trust me, this is a lot less cruel than it sounds. I am a huge advocate of animal safety and if I knew about prong collars before doing my research, I would immediately dismiss it.

The premise of prong collars is to keep your dog from constantly tugging in every direction when you are walking them. When you think about it, all the self-choking they do with a normal collar on cannot be any better for them in the long run. Prong collars are a lot safer than you might be thinking as well.

If you choose the right prong collar, you will find that your dog is much easier to walk. They will stop choking themselves and enjoy the walk more.

Bark Control Collars: Please Just Let Me Sleep!

this collar just control dog's bark

Lastly, we have a different type of shock collar. Unlike the remote shock collar, bark control shock collars are designed to shock your dog as soon as they bark. This collar should really only be considered if you have a dog that is constantly having barking issues when you are not around.

Typically used for outside dogs that bark aggressively at strangers, the bark control also adjustable like the remote shock collar. Some collars also come with a remote but activate automatically as well. If you are not comfortable with seeing your dog get punished, this is a good option.

A lot of times, we are forced to do what is necessary. It is not uncommon that neighbors complain about barking dogs. Even if your dog is right when he barks at that neighbor who annoys you, your landlord might think different. Luckily, there is also an alternative to shock collars.

Spray bark-control collars stop the barking before it even happens. According to the Humane Society’s Official website, spray collars will send out air or citronella to stop your dog from barking. Unfortunately, higher pitched barks do not typically pick up with these types of collars meaning you will need to find a different collar.

Properly Using Dog Training Collars

the important thing is proper use and choose best dog training collar for your dog

No matter what training collar you choose, proper use is always important. The last thing you want to do is hurt your dog. For that reason, you should think hard about your situation and figure out which collar will work best for you.

Each collar has a different way of ensuring your dog’s safety. For example, with shock collars, you should test the shock on yourself before using it on your dog. Getting a valid understanding of how powerful the shock is will show you what setting to use based on your dog's size.

Shock collars are very strong so you should not skip out on testing it. Now without further ado, let’s get on to the 5 best dog training collars available on today’s market:

​Dog Training Collar Reviews

  • This anti-bark collar uses no shock feature. It is a mixture of the shock bark control collar and regular shock collar. It uses safe round caps that produce a vibration that creates a stimulus that your dog can understand.
  • Very humane and does not harm your dog in any way. This is the best collar on our list for people who want to avoid inflicting pain on your dog at all costs.
  • With a built-in progression system, you do not have to manually activate the vibration. The collar works on a 7-level sensitivity system. So, when your dog barks once, the first level activates and as your dog continues to bark, the sensitivity increase.
  • thumbs-o-up
    Designed for long-haired and short-haired dogs. This collar is also a great small dog training collar.
  • Collar activates when any nearby dog barks so if you own multiple dogs or live by other dogs, you should keep this in mind.
  • Sensitivity is sometimes not intense enough to make your dog stop barking. Your dog can and will ignore it sometimes so all barking may not cease. This is especially true for bigger dogs like German Shepherds.

  • With both a rechargeable battery and remote control, you will never have to worry about buying batteries to use this collar.
  • Like most shock collars, the shock setting goes from 1 to 100. It is important though to test out how bad the shock is yourself. Do not use any previous collar you had as a reference as each collar can feel differently, settings 60 to 100 provide a painful experience with this collar.
  • This shock collar comes with three different modes: beep, vibration, and shock. A good method of using it is by using a tier system.
  • thumbs-o-up
    First, you should tell your dog no while using a beep. Then you should use the vibration if they have not stopped disobeying. Next, you should use the shock and eventually, your dog will associate the beep or vibration with a shock and the shock won’t be necessary anymore.
  • thumbs-o-up
    The range on this collar is very impressive. It works across your home through several walls. You can easily use it while you are inside and your dog is outside.
  • thumbs-o-up
    The collar also comes with multiple pairs of prongs that allow for you to adjust for your dog’s fur type (short prongs for short haired dogs and long prongs for long haired dogs.)
  • Though it has a rechargeable battery, there seems to be a limited lifespan to the device's battery. In this case, you will have to recharge it more and more as time goes on.
  • The clips that the strap goes around are not very strong and can break causing unusability.

  • Comes with two spray modes and a beep function. The first spray is a short spray and the second provides a longer spray. The spray does not smell good and discourages the bad behavior from your dogs while the beep gives your dog a warning that a spray is to come if they continue to behave badly.
  • The collar is completely waterproof. Even in pouring rain, you will not run into any significant issues.
  • Comes with pre-filled unscented spray while the refill is scented.
  • thumbs-o-up
    When using this collar to train, it is important to only use one or two commands at a time to avoid any confusion. Afterwards, you can move on so training might take a little longer with this collar.
  • This collar is best suited for indoor dogs or small outdoor areas. The range is only 80 yards or 240 feet respectively.
  • Uses 2 replaceable 6-volt alkaline batteries. There is no recharging capability with this collar. However, the batteries tend to last for a long time before replacement is needed.
  • thumbs-o-down
    Requires you to purchase refillable spray once you run out. The refills are somewhat expensive.
  • thumbs-o-down
    The collar does not sit very comfortably on your dog, so it is advised to only use while walking your dog.

  • Unlike most other shock collars, this collar contains a unique ‘tapping sensation’ feature that will send vibrations off as pulses instead of a continuous effect. However, even in the continuous mode, there are brief moments that the vibration will stop.
  • Another collar with outstanding range, the Educator works at over 1500 feet away. The claims that this collar can work at half a mile range seems valid.
  • Requires a daily charge as the battery life is short. Though not a con on its own, the charger included is complicated and requires a lot of effort just to charge.

  • This training collar lets you remove the hooks from the chain. This allows for you to create the optimal experience for your dog. It also helps with fitting the collar.
  • When using prong collars, it is very important to make sure that the collar fits just right and Herm Sprenger gives you an excellent way to ensure comfort and safety for your dog.
  • After testing this collar, you will notice that the prongs do not dig into the skin of your dog but rather gives more of a pinching feeling. It gives just enough pain to let your dog know not to pull against you.
  • thumbs-o-up
    A lot of times, rain will come out of nowhere while you are walking your dog. This collar deals with rain very well. It does not rust if it gets wet.
  • thumbs-o-up
    The best method to using this collar is to avoid pulling hard against your dog. Try to focus on only tugging with your wrist and not your elbow, shoulder, or bicep. Keep your dog alert as well by stopping, slowing down, and speeding up while walking.
  • Occasionally, ordering a size up is required for the best fit.
  • The design of this collar is not extensively sturdy. So, if your dog plays at it, it can easily come undone or lose prongs. Though it works well to keep your dog from pulling, if your dog does fight through the pain, they can unhook the collar.

​Which is the Best Dog Training Collar for You?

When it comes to training your dog, a lot of different methods can be implemented. We’ve discussed the different types of collars, but which one is the best? Looking over each collar, the Pro Pet Works No Bark Collar is the right choice for anyone trying to deal with a dog who excessively barks. Not inflicting pain on your dog just seems right, especially when their barking could be because they are simply afraid.

However, if you have a larger dog or your dog might ignore the non-intensive vibrations from the no shock bark control collar, you will have to look at a shock collar. If you are okay with using pain to correct your dog than the Esky Backlight Remote Dog Training Shock Collar is a great option. It has several settings for the shock sensitivity, rechargeable batteries, three modes for training, and impressive range.

The Pro Pet Works No Bark Collar is the most versatile collar on our list today. With it and proper usage of the collar, training your dog will be much easier.

Anna Sakila

Hi, I’m Anna Sakila and I love to give my friend the best of everything. I started this blog so I can also share my experiences with you. Take a tour through my site to see helpful stories and useful information on the best ways to care for your lovely dog.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply:

%d bloggers like this: